Monday, October 14, 2013

Sale on, big sick machine!

When it comes to explaining what I mean by my mantra, "No neat and tidy endings," sometimes a picture is worth more than a thousand words. Especially if it is a picture of words.

I have used mostly words and a few pictures to elucidate that oft-repeated message about no neat and tidy endings, with my most recent posts focusing on the carrion feeders who are now circling the remains of serial scammer Kevin Trudeau's scammy Global Information Network (GIN). There is, for example,
an ex-KT b.f.f., Matt DuBiel, formerly of KTRN Radio Network, who has been busy exploiting his Katie connection to push new scams.

But this picture... well, to me it illustrates in an even more poignant way that the end of GIN will not be the end of similar scams, nor of the scammers who have so clearly benefited from GIN. It also illustrates that GIN and Katie have left a mighty legacy that will survive no matter what happens with the civil case or the upcoming criminal trial. In fact, GIN and Katie's most lasting legacy seems to be that they have provided second- or third-string scammers with a larger platform.


The shot above is from a Facebook page devoted to planning an alternative to the annual GIN Leadership Cruise. The actual GIN Leadership Cruise has been cancelled due to Katie's legal problems finally catching up with him. The GINtanic may really be sinking this time, and if GIN doesn't go away, it will almost certainly be re-branded without Katie.

But it seems clear that those events will make barely a dent in the big sick machine.


Out of respect for the privacy of the people planning this alt-cruise (I had previously applauded them for seemingly planning for life after Katie and GIN), I redacted all names except for the high-profile huckster and long-time Trudeau friend who is apparently going to be on board with the sea-gullibles. That huckster is of course Fred Van Liew, who has been an honored guest on my Whirled previously.

Please don't take this as victim-bashing in any way, but I have to say this: As long as people are willing to believe in stupid things (like the GIN Council, and the ability of third-rate hucksters to "heal" energetically), there will be people to take advantage of that willingness.
 
A Facebook friend recently indicated on one of the self-proclaimed "GIN destroyer" Facebook pages that fighting scams is like a game of Whack-a-Mole. That's an apt comparison. And while said "GIN destroyers" are high-fiving each other and claiming victory because of the apparently eminent demise of GIN, those of us with a more realistic perspective know that there will be no Hollywood ending to this story... and really, no ending at all.

PS added 17 October 2013: The Fred Van Loony alt-GIN cruise is causing quite a buzz on the GIN destroyer pages, and once again another Loony -- that would be Mocktor Loony Coldwell -- engages in some pot-calling-kettle action by accusing Fred of being a fondler who is "practicing medicine without a license." Click to enlarge if you need to -- particularly the second pic, which shows Loony Coldwell at his echolaliac best (or worst).


Hello?!? Hands-on "healing, anyone?

* * * * *
Now more than ever, your donation is needed
to help keep this Whirled spinning.
Click here to donate via PayPal or debit/credit card.
If that link doesn't work, send PayPal payment directly to

scrivener66@hotmail.com
or to
cosmic.connie@juno.com
If PayPal, be sure to specify that your contribution is a gift. Thank you!

Saturday, October 12, 2013

Another GIN scavenger: "carrion" on a proud Scamworld tradition

As serial scammer Kevin Trudeau's GIN scampire continues to disintegrate in the face of the receivership and the looming court cases, the scavengers are circling, and have been for most of this year, picking off the flesh before the beast is even dead. There's the IBMS Master's Society, founded by Trudeau's ex-b.f.f. Mocktor Leonard Coldwell and Trudeau's ex-marketing guy Peter Wink.

But if you think that the IMBS-ing U Master Baiter's Seekrit Society is the only GIN-n-Katie scavenger game in town, you'd be sadly mistaken. Another scavenger, one Matt DuBiel, formerly of KTRN Radio Network but still a force to be reckoned with on Internet radio, has also been circling the near-kill. He's been a busy little carrion feeder over the past few days.

A few days ago a former GIN member sent me a copy of an email Matt had sent out, promoting a new "course" by a guy who calls himself The Nomad Capitalist.

From: KTRNusa@gmail.com
Subject: he got his freedom back!
Date: 9 October, 2013 1:07:33 PM EDT
To:

Hi [Name]!
My good friend recently took matters into his own hands to reclaim his FREEDOM from this police state.
I just got off the phone with him...
He literally just put the finishing touches on an amazing in depth online course that will teach us how to do the same.
He's calling it Offshore 101, but that's a fancy way of saying "take your freedom back and use whatever countries will help you".
He likes to say, go where you are treated BEST...for banking, for citizenship, for business, for travel...
This Offshore 101 Course is SIX HOURS of amazing information they don't want you to know about...and it's 100% LEGAL!
It's broken up into 10 parts so you can start and stop as needed.
He sells this course online for $200, but I asked him to give people I know 50% off...AND HE AGREED, but this special expires tomorrow at midnight.
Grab this now and learn how to reclaim your freedom.
Use the DISCOUNT CODE: radio
CLICK HERE [link removed by me ~CC] TO GET 50% NOW
You'll get HALF off immediately!  But do it before midnight tomorrow.
P.S.  Learn how to reclaim your GLOBAL freedom, get 50% off the best 6 hours of material available on the subject...click here [link removed by me ~ CC] and use the discount code radio.
The "Nomad Capitalist" is one Andrew Henderson. Though Kevin himself more than likely had nothing to do with this email, it's still more than a little ironic that it's coming from someone even remotely associated with Kevin, when Kevin's own attempts to become a "free" citizen of the world -- more specifically, to hide his assets in far flung corners of the globe -- are a big part of why he is in the mess in which he currently finds himself.

But you have to pity poor Matt, who had one of his big platforms and income streams snatched out from under him when that mean receiver closed down the KTRN site. Another ex-GIN pal just got this in the emails yesterday:

From: "KTRNusa@gmail.com
Date: October 11, 2013 at 3:57:01 PM EDT
To:
Subject: they killed KTRN..
Hey...
Did you see the KTRN site has been taken down???
Who knows what they'll take down next...
I'm emailing because I am building a team of super motivated go-getters...and I'd like you to consider joining me.This is going to be like NOTHING you've ever been a part of.
It's got HUGE money making potential, the members are tip notch..and I got started for $25.
You can use this to promote your other MLMs, Network Marketing businesses, websites...you name it. 
The internet training is where you really get tremendous value though. 
You'll learn how to actually use the web to make money instead of waste time!
People who get on my team early are going to get media perks and special mastermind opportunities....
My group will use radio and tv to make this explode...
Get in now.  I'm telling ya!  This started AFTER GIN...and it's now BIGGER by over 100x.
This video explains everything.
Best,
Matt
P.S.  Watch this free video [link removed by me ~CC] and let's make something cool happen!
Can you guess what this big op is, boys and girls? That's right, it's the scammy, scummy Empower Network's scummiest scam yet -- BlogBeast. (Empower has been thoroughly covered on Omri's Glancingweb blog and lately visited by the Salty Droid as well.)

You really can't blame Matt for exploiting his GIN and Katie creds, even indirectly, and trying to pick up the pieces of his Scamworld career by exploring other opportunities. Like most of Katie's former cohorts, Matt may feel a bit betrayed by Katie's duplicity, not to mention that he may be feeling desperate, now that the sure thing he had has been taken away. That's probably why he felt he had little to lose when reportedly spilling some info to Peter Wink last year, which Peter shared on Facebook earlier this year (I didn't screen-shoot the conversations but they ended up on the Quatloos forum, whose members apparently didn't realize that Abe was not a "high level" GIN member):
...I also had a phone conversation shorty [sic] after I was done with GIN with Matt DuBiel of KTRN who told me that he taped the entire Your Wish is Your Command program for KT in Chicago, so everything fell right into place...
You'll have to consider the source(s), but in this instance I believe Peter was telling the truth and that Matt was too, regarding the taping of Your Wish Is Your Command.

At any rate, I strongly suspect that the Nomad Capitalist and BlogBeast ops are not the last we'll be hearing from Matt, and I expect that Matt will not be the last of the former Katie cohorts to try to continue to make his way in Scamworld, using Katie and GIN in any way they can. That's how it works: the big sick machine just hums on and on and on. Even if (when) GIN dies or is totally re-branded without Katie, and even if Katie ends up rockin' the orange for a while, Scamworld will live on.

You know... no neat and tidy endings.


* * * * *
Now more than ever, your donation is needed
to help keep this Whirled spinning.
Click here to donate via PayPal or debit/credit card.
If that link doesn't work, send PayPal payment directly to

scrivener66@hotmail.com
or to
cosmic.connie@juno.com
If PayPal, be sure to specify that your contribution is a gift. Thank you!

Tuesday, October 08, 2013

James Arthur Ray and the deaths in Sedona: Four. Long. Years.


Another year has passed, and here we are at another sad anniversary. Four years after his recklessness* killed Kirby Brown and James Shore, and fatally injured Liz Neuman,** in a phony sweat lodge in Sedona, Arizona, selfish-help guru and star of The Secret James Arthur Ray is out of prison, presumably planning his comeback tour in Scamworld. I still find it appalling that he served less than two years in an Arizona prison for those deaths, and has yet to answer for another death a few months previously, that of Colleen Conaway in a San Diego shopping mall.

A couple of weeks ago I heard from Ginny Brown, the mother of Kirby Brown. She apparently came across my blog by way of doing research into the Kevin Trudeau/James Ray connection. (As regulars know, I've written about the True-dough/Death Ray connection numerous times on this blog, such as here and here. And I have commemorated it pictorially as well.) Ginny wanted me to help spread the word about the nonprofit organization she founded in the wake of her daughter's untimely death. This is SEEKsafely, Inc., and it is dedicated, she wrote, "to educating the public about self-help, empowering seekers and promoting ethical and safe practices in the self-help industry."

I already knew about SEEKsafely, having mentioned it a couple of times on my blog,
including on this post from this past July. I promised Ginny that I would mention it today as well, because I had planned to write another commemorative post, as I have done every year since the Sedona tragedy happened. (This was my first commemorative post -- an inordinately long one, framed in a review of Connie Joy's book, Tragedy in Sedona.)

Ginny explained to me that
SEEKsafely is trying to take a positive approach to what she and many others see as a very troubling self-help phenomenon. "As long as traditional religions fail to bring people spiritual growth and personal fulfillment, people’s search for meaning and purpose will continue with the self-help industry working to fill that personal need," she wrote. "In the midst of the scams there are sincere teachers who do offer legitimate help and support...  While I do not want SEEK to promote, endorse or monitor self-help providers, we do want to create change in the industry and educate the consumer."

Though I have never been a bastion of positivity, I see the value in Ginny's approach. I agree with her that traditional religion has failed us in many ways, and that is why people seek alternatives that sometimes are not safe. I told her I think that because of her own experience and background (she is a therapist and retreat leader, coming from a Catholic background), and of course because of the tragic loss she suffered, she is in a unique position to effect some changes in an industry that is here to stay but is very much in need of change.

I know that here on this blog my own views often come across as much more on the cynical side (though I continue to insist that it a cynicism I have earned honestly), but the truth is that I remain sympathetic to the quest for meaning in life.*** What riles me is the way that the selfish-help and McSpirituality gurus so often take advantage of people's deepest hungers and fears and longings.

And I told Ginny that I think it speaks volumes that so many of the most well-known self-help/motivational/spiritual gurus to whom her organization reached out have still not signed
the SEEKsafely Promise. Here is the list of those who have not signed. I told her that I agree with her that there are some good, sincere people in the industry, and actually I think that many if not most start out with the best of intentions (I honestly don't think we can say that about Ray, however). However, it seems to me that this industry attracts many people who, once they reach a certain level of fame and fortune, all too often become more concerned with promoting their "brand" than with anything else.

Perhaps some of the gurus don't think that a pledge such as the SEEKsafely Promise applies to them because they don't conduct "extreme" workshops (or in some cases they conduct few if any workshops at all).

Some may be reluctant to acknowledge that a workshop doesn't have to be physically extreme, on the order of a desert vision quest or a sweat lodge, in order to be dangerous. But as many people have learned the hard way, many of the Large Group Awareness Training events are emotionally and psychologically grueling, and have occasionally been known to spur psychotic episodes in vulnerable people --
sometimes with tragic consequences.

In addition, it is possible that some of the gurus feel there is too much potential liability in signing such a pledge, fearing that by doing so they might weaken or compromise those elaborate "waivers" they have participants sign before their events.

All of this is speculation on my part, of course, but I suspect that it is fairly well-informed speculation.

I told Ginny that I applaud what she is doing with SEEKsafely, and added that although I did not have the pleasure of knowing Kirby personally, I feel I know her, at least a little, through Ginny's words and those of others who knew and loved her. And it seems to me that she would be very pleased with Ginny's efforts to help others...well... seek safely.

It seems to me, though, that in order for people to be able to seek safely, a little negativity is definitely in order. Towards that end, it is up to all of us who care about these issues to make sure that the world never forgets what James Arthur Ray did four long years ago.

Here again is the link to SEEKsafely, Inc.

Update, 13 October, 2013: Saturday, October 12 marked the end of community supervision in Arizona for James Ray. He was expected to return to California, presumably to hit the comeback trail in earnest, so I guess we need to keep our eyes open for his next trick.
 
Recent and related on this Whirled:


* Technically, James Arthur Ray was convicted of, and served time for, three counts of negligent homicide, rather than reckless manslaughter. Being negligent carries less of a prison sentence than being reckless. But eyewitness accounts point to utter recklessness at best, and at worst... well, anyway, he's out now.
** Kirby Brown and James Shore died on October 8, 2009, and Liz Neuman lay in a coma for nine days before her family finally made the painful decision to withdraw life support on October 17, 2009.

*** As many probably know, I'm actually "on the fence" about many things and, as noted above, I remain sympathetic in general to people's search for meaning. In case you haven't seen these yet, here are a couple of blog posts I wrote years ago, when both The Secret and this blog were pretty new:
* * * * *
Now more than ever, your donation is needed
to help keep this Whirled spinning.
Click here to donate via PayPal or debit/credit card.
If that link doesn't work, send PayPal payment directly to

scrivener66@hotmail.com
or to
cosmic.connie@juno.com
If PayPal, be sure to specify that your contribution is a gift. Thank you!

Friday, October 04, 2013

MLM: Kevin Trudeau's GIN is just one toxic drop in a huge ocean of fraud

Inspired by Barbara, a regular commenter on the Salty Droid blog

All you have to do to succeed :: is succeed at convincing others that they can succeed at succeeding … just by convincing others to succeed.
It’s that simple {of a mindf--k}.
Why aren’t you doing it?
Oh and also :: it will most likely tear your life apart … and ruin everything.
~
Salty Droid, on the MLM monster, 4 October 2013

Statistically, 997 of every 1,000 MLM recruits will sustain a net loss over the course of their involvement.
~ "Roger Willco," anti-MLM activist, in a comment on
a July 2013 Salty Droid blog post

For the past few months I've been focusing a lot -- perhaps even a bit too much -- on the courtroom dramas of serial scammer Kevin Trudeau. I know some of you are probably getting a little bored with that, and perhaps you wish I would either get back to my old-Whirled roots of just writing about the silly and wackadoodle aspects of New-Wage/selfish-help/McSpirituality culture (I know you're still out there, HHH!). Others of you probably think I should turn my attention again to some of the larger and more serious problems, of which Kevin Trudeau and his scammy, Ponzi-like Global Information Network (GIN) are but one smallish part.

Well, I agree with all of you. Everyday I see silly wackadoodle things that are seriously blogworthy, so don't give up on me, HHH. But today, I fear, we are going to have to be a little more seriously serious, because I was reminded again of the larger and more serious problems when reading Salty Droid's blog post today, which features a "confesstimonial" from one Roger Willco (not his real name). Roger in recent years has become an activist against multi-level marketing, or MLM, for several very good reasons. Some of those reasons will become painfully obvious when you read Roger's story on the above-linked Salty post.

Now, before I go any further, understand that I have no intention of abandoning my courtroom vigil (or PACER.gov vigil, as the case may be) where True-dough is concerned. (I updated my most recent Katie blog post just now, with a link to more court documents filed today. Here's the link to the post; scroll to the bottom.)

And in fact, today's blog post about multilevel marketing and the damage it does is related to Trudeau and GIN as well, because Trudeau has been involved in MLMs for decades himself -- starting with Amway, and then, after his prison stint, going on to Nutrition for Life, as well as grooming
Barb and Dave Pitcock, who made their fortunes with an MLM they call Livinity, which last year merged with another MLM called Youngevity, which is run by veterinarian and naturopath Joel Wallach... and oh, the bigness and the sickness of the big sick machine -- even just True-dough's part of it -- boggles the mind, but this sentence is already far too long, so I'd better cut it off now.

As most of you are well aware, one of Trudeau's biggest schemes to date,
GIN, has a significant MLM arm, in which thousands of people over the few years GIN has been in operation have placed their hard-earned money, as well as their hopes and dreams of achieving the lavish lifestyle and pure happiness that Trudeau always bragged about. The "product" being sold via that MLM is a Level One GIN membership, which costs $1,000 for the "initiation" and $150 per month thereafter. Members are strongly and unceasingly encouraged -- pressured, actually -- to upgrade to ever more expensive levels of membership. That all seemed to be working out fine for a while; well, at least it worked to put money in Trudeau's pockets and those of a few of his cronies and KT's lawyers. It appears that almost everyone else lost money, though many are still unwilling to admit it.

These days, due to Trudeau's own long-standing legal troubles, GIN too is clearly in all sorts of trouble, with even
the court-appointed receiver, Robb Evans and Associates, raising questions about the legitimacy of GIN as an MLM. The receiver says there is no real "product" -- fancy that. Of course this story isn't over yet. I'm watching it.

But
today's post on the Salty Droid blog focuses on MLMs in general, with a story told by someone who was once very close to a serial MLM junkie, and saw firsthand how MLM devotion can wreck bank accounts and lives. And I think you need to read it. Roger Willco actually lays out dollar figures of how much his ex spent on MLM products and recruiting "tools," versus how little she made, as she worked her way through one MLM after another after another after another. Her story is far from atypical. It's much more the rule than the exception.

Following his narrative, Roger very concisely reiterates what is fundamentally wrong with MLMs:

The MLM business model is reliant on convincing prospects of two foundational fictions:
  • There is an endless chain of prospective distributors.
  • There is a perpetually virgin market for the products being sold.
If prospective distributors aren’t at least implicitly convinced these two fictions are actually truths, an MLM cannot even launch, let alone survive.
Other pertinent points from Roger:





  • Only a very few MLM distributors eventually become knowing perpetrators of predatory fraud.  Their prey are new recruits, many of whom become unwitting predators as well.  Unaware participants lose their money—sometimes all of it, rack up debt—often insurmountable, sully or destroy some or all of their personal relationships and give up their personal credibility.  Most of what they sacrifice can never be recovered.
  • They are the victims of the most pervasive and costly ongoing business opportunity fraud in America—15.6 million victims losing in aggregate, $15 billion in 2012, according to forensic accountant and certified fraud investigator, Tracy Coenen.
  • When these unfortunate victims run out of money, credit and other external means of support, they tiptoe out of the industry—embarrassed and convinced they were the cause of their own failure.  They “didn’t work hard enough”, they “didn’t follow the system well enough” or they “didn’t believe enough”.  And because of their embarrassment, they seldom complain to regulators.
  • That latter point explains why more ex-GIN MLM-ers haven't publicly spoken out about their money and just how much they lost. And even with all of the media publicity about GIN, many may never speak out. Many would rather just forget it, including, apparently, one former "Inner Circle" GIN member who spent more than $130,000 in GIN. That person was a member of a private Facebook forum in which I also participated, but the person now seems to be M.I.A.

    Roger has contributed previously to Salty's blog (and on mine too). On a July 30, 2013 blog post about Herbalife on Salty's blog, Roger wrote:
    Pyramid standards are the biggest among many problems inhibiting FTCs enforcement of consumer protections against MLM abuses. Whether or not any company can classify the requisite percentage of sales as “retail” is nothing more than a red herring to which the commission has been susceptible since the 1979 Amway case. It’s unclear if Amway purposely concocted “pyramid standards” to suit their purpose. However it’s served the MLM industry well in keeping the the FTC at bay. Any MLM relying on the promise of exponential growth to recruit distributors (are there any that don’t?) is running a pyramid scheme.
    In fact, conceptualization of exponential growth progressions as anything remotely resembling a pyramid is simply fallacious. A binary growth model (one recruits two who each recruit two who each in turn recruit two and so on), can only reach 32 levels before the entire population of the planet–every man, woman and child–is exceeded…not really new information. But if one graphs the same model such that each level is represented as one inch high and each recruit is represented as one inch wide the resulting figure is 32 inches tall and 67,786 MILES wide–essentially an extremely long flat line with an imperceptible peak in the middle. By any reasonable analysis, such a growth pattern is completely unsustainable. MLM proponents will try to throw wrinkles into this mathematical reality; but the core principle remains unchanged. If a trinary or greater model is used, as is the case with most MLMs, the line is even flatter.
    Statistically, 997 of every 1,000 MLM recruits will sustain a net loss over the course of their involvement.
    Until the Commission recognizes they’ve been sidetracked by a red herring and understands that the MLM model is, in all cases, flawed, they’ll remain paralyzed in their enforcement of consumer protections against MLM abuses.
    I’ll concur with whatever profanity Salty Droid applies to this unfortunate circumstance.
    In my opinion, the least costly way to curb MLM fraud is for the FTC to mandate and monitor accurate disclosure of historical income data to prospects by those seeking to recruit them into any MLM “business (bankruptcy) opportunity. The industry contends that such disclosures would severely impede their ability to recruit distributors…No shit! And they’ve successfully lobbied MLM’s exemption from the disclosure requirements of the Commission’s recently promulgated Business Opportunity Rule. Interesting posture for an industry that promises incredible wealth to its prospective distributors. If their promises were well founded, it sorta seems like they’d jump at every opportunity to trumpet them.

    The day after Roger made that comment, another frequent and spot-on Salty Droid participant, Barbara, wrote on another Salty post:
    @ Roger Willco,
    Yesterday you wrote:
    “Statistically, 997 of every 1,000 MLM recruits will sustain a net loss over the course of their involvement.”
    I’m embroidering that on a sampler right now. It seems more important than Home Is Where The Heart Is.
    I cannot embroider worth a crap, but I have become quite proficient at crude Photoshopping.


    Some damage can never be undone
    Sometimes MLMs -- and the self-improvement culture that supports and enables them -- can cause (or contribute to) much more than financial, psychological, emotional, and spiritual damage to the participants and/or those who love them. Sometimes, lives are lost. There is a tragic epilogue to the narrative above, but it has to be told right, and we're still working out those details. Suffice to say for now that there is an MLM as well as a self-improvement LGAT (Large Group Awareness Training) connection to the tragedy.

    One thing I've noticed from my own firsthand observations is that MLM people just love them that "self- improvement" stuff. They are drawn to it like hipsters to upscale food trucks. (I think I've used that simile before but what the heck, here it is again.) MLM-ers are often enthusiastic consumers and promoters not only of their MLM but also of various self-improvement groups and LGATs. The tragic story in question seems to be an an undeniable example of how MLM involvement leads to suspended critical thinking, rendering followers susceptible to the many prosperity and self-improvement cults that orbit around MLM and rely on their victims' diminished analytical ability to get into their wallets.

    This case is particularly sad because it involves someone who, thanks to strong MLM influences, began involvement with a self-improvement LGAT as a youth. As you may know, most of these LGAT orgs have youth and kid versions, because they like to start 'em young. (
    Access Consciousness is one particularly disturbing example.)

    I'll tell more as soon as I can. The story is too important not to be told right. I've written before about the darker side of LGATs, and how they can sometimes contribute to psychotic episodes that result in suicide or other violent acts.
    Here's one example. And the terrible tale of James Arthur Ray follower Colleen Conaway, told in such poignant detail on Salty Droid's blog, appears to be another example of what can happen when disastrously unqualified "leaders" recklessly mess with the psyches of vulnerable people.

    We don't just have to sit idly by and take it.
    Roger Willco tells me he is currently directing many of his efforts, both individually and as part of an anti-MLM consortium/coalition, to persuading the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) to open an investigation of the entire MLM industry. One point of contention is the FTC's explicit exclusion of MLMs (presumably including GIN’s MLM program) from the disclosure provisions of its revised Business Opportunity Rule (16 CFR Part 437 -- here is a direct link). Activists want the FTC to rescind that exclusion. As Roger noted in another comment to Salty's "Falsifyingly Herbalife" blog post, the documents linked to in the previous sentence...
    ...make repeated references to the cooperation, goodwill and good rapport that exists between the [MLM] industry and the FTC. While this commentary doesn't constitute a slam-dunk admission of agency capture, it's perilously close; and it indicates the sort of relationship I'd hope wouldn't exist between an industry and the government agency charged with regulating it.
    (I've long said that if Katie had just stuck to MLM-ing his GINfolk -- using some of the proceeds to pay on that big FTC fine, instead of doing everything he could to dodge the fine and hide his assets overseas -- the FTC would have been cool with it, since they seem to have a cozy relationship with MLMs in general. Trudeau could have avoided several if not all of the contempt charges that now threaten to land him in prison. And he could have avoided most of the Ponzi accusations (accurate or not) if he'd avoided some of those dodgy bonus schemes and Lazyman promos and incentive deals that initially got some of the troops complaining in early 2012.)

    "There are some 20-30 other consumer advocates currently active in the anti-MLM cause," Roger tells me, "addressing the issues in several different ways; and among them, they’ve made a tremendous amount of good information available to the public."

    But Roger thinks that ongoing education efforts, including informative blogs such as Salty Droid's, and hey, even snarky blogs like this one, are an important part of the equation as well.

    As for the ex? Roger tells me that his ex has informed him she has "given up recruiting" for MLM. But, he says, "She's now an ardent GIN member and buys Trudeau's BS about his messianic qualities." 


    And so it goes, with the big sick machine sucking 'em in and spitting 'em out, and then lathering, rinsing, and repeating (I apologize for the mixed metaphors). One big problem is that so many people, either because of desperate circumstances or chronic deep denial, are willing to crawl right back in and start over, again and again and again and again. And the scammers will scam on, as long as there are people who are willing, against all rational evidence and horrid reality, to believe in them.

    But make no mistake: this isn't a blame-the-victim screed. The onus is still on the scammers not to scam, and on the regulatory agencies to regulate, and enforce those regulations, responsibly.

    As Salty says, "It’s not that we can’t do something about it … it’s just that we haven’t."

    But we can.

    This may be a good beginning. I expect more links to be coming to this page soon.


    A little related history: Back in Time with the big sick machine 

    * * * * *
    Now more than ever, your donation is needed
    to help keep this Whirled spinning.
    Click here to donate via PayPal or debit/credit card.
    If that link doesn't work, send PayPal payment directly to

    scrivener66@hotmail.com
    or to
    cosmic.connie@juno.com
    If PayPal, be sure to specify that your contribution is a gift. Thank you!


    Wednesday, October 02, 2013

    Shutdown, schmutdown: Kevin Trudeau case still provides plenty of entertainment

    Kevin Trudeau may not be so lucky, if the government has its way.
    Shutdown or not, the cases against him seem to be proceeding.

    The shutdown of the U.S. government is making many people furious, and rightly so, but for many folks, particularly those of us who have been following serial scammer Kevin Trudeau's courtroom dramas, the governmental glitch offers plenty of entertainment bang for the buck (or for the government's lack of bucks, as the case may be).

    But before we get to the entertainment part, let's recap the recent developments with the civil and criminal court cases. First off,
    as noted on this Whirled yesterday, the FTC has petitioned the court for an indefinite delay in the next (civil case) hearing for Katie. This is a change from their earlier granted motion to move the October 1 hearing to October 4 [see update below, though]. As they wrote on Document 761, filed October 1, 2013:
    As the Court is aware, on September 30, 2013, appropriations to the FTC lapsed. The FTC does not know when Congress will restore funding. Without appropriations, FTC attorneys are legally prohibited from working except in limited circumstances. Accordingly, the FTC requests that the Court reset the proceeding scheduled for Friday, October 4 to three days after the Commission resumes operation, or to the earliest available time thereafter.
    So that means that in the matter involving that hefty $37.6 million FTC fine -- the matter which brought all of his assets under receivership -- Kevin is free for now, though not off the hook, unless Judge Gettleman decides otherwise. (And at this point, nothing would surprise me, although Judge Gettleman seems to have been growing sterner with Katie in recent hearings.) The second part of Document 761 is the part where it looks as if the FTC lawyers are throwing their hands up in despair, or at the very least giving themselves an out should the case collapse:
    Over the past year, the FTC has done everything it reasonably could to move this proceeding forward as rapidly as possible, because moving quickly best serves consumers interests. As we have argued before, significant redress becomes less likely as more time elapses. Accordingly, the FTC is disappointed that it must seek this relief, and the FTC respectfully requests that the Court reset the next proceeding to three days after the Commission resumes operation, or to the earliest available time thereafter.
    Translation: "We've done everything we can do to help the consumers, but OTHER people keep these delays going, so what's a girl to do?"

    Now, the entertaining part is that even though I haven't yet seen any official statement from Katie, some of his followers, having heard the news of the indefinite postponement, are high-fiving it on Facebook and saying, "Yessssss! This is it! We won!" Some are dead certain that Katie will even show up for the GIN Family Reunion in Washington D.C. later this month (
    it's scheduled for October 18-20). If so, there may be that hero's welcome after all -- the Return of the King scenario I envisioned others envisioning on this recent blog post

    And this comes as no surprise whatsoever, but some are even saying that Katie used the power of his mighty mind to shut down the government, and that he can do it whenever he wants to.


    It won't be the first time that true believers have ascribed supernatural or magical powers to their hero/idol. I expect we'll see more of the same re Katie as time goes by and delays continue. He will somehow manage to milk each seemingly good turn of fortune for all it's worth, putting his own spin on it and pandering to the true believers. Even if he remains silent, there's plenty of adulation to go around, and the believers themselves will fill in the gaps.

    That's what people do, particularly when one of their heroes is in obvious trouble.

    But the wrench in the works, which I've mentioned here a few times previously, is that no matter what happens with the civil case, which is far from over anyway, there's still that criminal contempt case. Though anything could conceivably happen to delay or even vacate that case, at this point
    it appears to be going forth as scheduled (as also noted here yesterday). A status hearing was held on September 30, and another one is set for October 10. And the government shutdown does not seem to be affecting any of it.

    Indeed,
    as this September 30 Reuters article indicates, it's pretty much going to be business as usual in many of the courts across our great land, including (for now, at least) in the Northern District of Illinois, where Trudeau's criminal as well as civil case is being heard.

    Thomas Bruton, the court clerk for the Northern District of Illinois in Chicago, said officials there would not make any determination regarding essential staff until they know for certain that the shutdown will last more than two weeks.
    The Reuters piece goes on to say...
    The memo from the courts' central administrative office said judges should not prioritize between criminal and civil cases. During a shutdown, courts would eschew non-essential expenses, such as training, purchasing equipment and supplies and paying for travel.
    While judges would continue to hear cases, the Justice Department said it would ask to postpone appearances in civil and bankruptcy cases as long as it did not compromise the safety of human life or the protection of property under the terms of the Anti-Deficiency Act.
    The courts' administrative office instructed judges to "be sympathetic" to such requests. In the event that a judge orders a government attorney to appear, the Justice Department said it would comply and provide the minimum staffing needed to do so.
    Criminal cases would continue to be heard without delay or interruption, the Justice Department said.
    So there's that. The point to remember is that the plaintiff in the civil case is the FTC. The criminal case, however, is being prosecuted by the U.S. Attorney's office.

    But wait, there's more! That is, there's more entertainment to be squeezed out of this latest turn of events. With the civil case on hold indefinitely for now, it appears as if some of the anti-GIN contingent have jumped on the "Kevin Trudeau is old news" bandwagon with Kevin's ex-marketing guy Peter Wink. Over the past few months Peter has vacillated between mouthing off about the scandalous scandals that may be going on behind the scenes with the KT court cases, and declaring that KT is old news and not important any more. In between these outbursts he's mostly silent (and, I imagine, seething). Now it seems that his fellow Supreme Founder of the IBMS Master's Society scam, Loony Coldwell, has also taken up the call, as have the Supreme Founders' little bruppet (brother/puppet), Abe Husein.

    Whatever happened to those lawsuits Loony was talking about just last week? If GIN didn't get shut down at the September 26 hearing, and if Katie didn't get thrown in jail, why,
    Loony was going to sic his entire legal team at Merritt Webb on to the court-appointed receiver, the receiver's attorney, the FTC, and possibly the judge. But this week he has uttered not a peep about it, just a comment that Katie is unimportant in the big picture (see pics below).

    My take on the seeming turnaround is that since the very latest developments make it more apparent that -- AHEM! -- there will be no neat and tidy endings, Loony and his bruppet have changed their tune about the significance of the court cases in order to save face. But they and some of the toadies say KT is ruined thanks to Abe, anyway. (
    There's even a funny comment on one of Salty Droid's old blog posts. I don't think the guy was being sarcastic, either.)

    Below is a Facebook exchange that started yesterday and has continued today. Hmmm. It looks like that Kalea person is cruising for a good blocking... the fate of so many before her. Maybe it's because, as my friend Tim likes to say, truth is like Kryptonite for Loony and his pals. But what do they need with truth? Truth is boring, when it comes right down to it. They have more exciting things on their plate, such as an upcoming "Hollywood movie," with Abe as the script consultant and possibly as assistant screenwriter. As I've noted before, if it even gets into production, much less release, it may not be at all truthful, but it should be rollicking good entertainment.
    (Click on pics to enlarge.)

    There's even greater entertainment afoot. Abe hinted at it in his opening salvo in the exchange above, and numerous others have mentioned it too. They're saying that the US government shutdown isn't even real -- that it's a New World Order scam, and is the first step towards enslaving the citizenry. A few examples...


    And then there's this.

    Break out the tinfoil hats, kids!

    So if this gummit shutdown has you worried because you're an employee on forced furlough and you have a family to support and a mortgage to pay... or because you're not getting desperately needed benefits or services... or even because you just had your long-awaited, all-planned-out-and-paid-for family vacation blown all to hell -- yeah, that's right, the vacation where you were going to take the kids to the Smithsonian or one of the national parks for the experience of a lifetime... stop that worrying. All of you! Right this instant. The government may not be functioning, but as long as the Interwebz continue to function, there will be plenty of entertainment. Look for the gold, Dear Ones. Look for the gold.

    Update: This just in...n
    otwithstanding the government shutdown and the FTC's expression of seeming despair on October 1, the agency appears to be going ahead with the civil case. The status hearing that was continued from September 26 to October 1, and then changed to October 4, and then moved again due to uncertainty regarding the government shutdown, is now set for Wednesday, October 16 at 1:30 PM.
    Update 4 October, 2013: More court documents came in today. Blair Zanzig, the attorney for the court-appointed receiver, Robb Evans and Associates, has issued a statement about why coercive sanctions -- jail, in other words -- is the only way to get Trudeau to FINALLY come clean about his finances. This is Document 764 with five exhibits,filed on 10-04-13

    The exhibits are as noteworthy as the statement, and they include Katie explaining that he is just a hard-working boy who, for the past ten years, has worked his a$$ off and didn't have time to bother his head with finances. He spent his time traveling and researching and speaking and writing copy and writing books and doing his radio show and oh, so many other things that had nothing -- nothing! -- to do with keeping track of where all his money is. He had Neil Sant and Marc Lane and Michael Dow to do all of that boring stuff.

    The US government shutdown is still hampering the case, of course, and if the government shutdown is not resolved, there could be further delays. I'm thinking that Judge Gettleman could probably choose to incarcerate Trudeau now, as it seems he has heard more than enough evidence to incarcerate him for violating the terms of the court's recent orders. But according to two other documents, 763 and 765, also filed on 10-04-13, Trudeau has until 10-11-13 to reply both to the receiver's statement and the FTC's previous statement
    (Document 759 and exhibit, filed 09/30/13) regarding the need for coercive sanctions.
    * * * * *
    Now more than ever, your donation is needed
    to help keep this Whirled spinning.
    Click here to donate via PayPal or debit/credit card.
    If that link doesn't work, send PayPal payment directly to

    scrivener66@hotmail.com
    or to
    cosmic.connie@juno.com
    If PayPal, be sure to specify that your contribution is a gift. Thank you!

    Tuesday, October 01, 2013

    Kevin Trudeau update: Katie is free...indefinitely, maybe


    My little graphic for my previous post was even more prescient than I realized.
    This came in just a while ago from our intrepid reporter Phil Rogers at NBC5 Chicago, and was confirmed by popping on to PACER to see the FTC crying, "Uncle!" (See graphic above; click to enlarge.)
    Infomercial king Kevin Trudeau has the United States Congress to thank for his freedom.
    By shutting down the government, lawmakers have also shut down the federal lawyers attempting to throw Trudeau in jail.
    Today, those attorneys for the Federal Trade Commission reluctantly told Judge Robert Gettleman that because of the government shutdown, they have no money to pursue the case against Trudeau. Because of that, they asked that a scheduled Oct. 4 hearing be indefinitely postponed.
    For Trudeau, the delay could not come at a better time...
    ...For now, it appears Trudeau has a temporary ticket to the outside world...
    At least until the criminal trial, which is being prosecuted by the U.S. Attorney's office... but that too may be postponed. Indefinitely. (Although it seems, for now, that things are proceeding as if it's really going to happen on schedule.)

    Kevin Trudeau: FTC still calling for jail, while court hearing is postponed due to government shutdown


    Happy October, y'all! September was a busy month on this Whirled because it was an active month in the courts for serial scammer Kevin Trudeau and his nemesis, the US Federal Trade Commission (FTC). The civil hearing that took place on September 26, and
    for which Trudeau's loudest and looniest detractors held out such high hopes, was originally continued to today, October 1. The Loony was not happy about that, no-siree.

    But subsequently the FTC lawyers, with the blessings of Katie's lawyers, filed an emergency motion to move the hearing to later in the week, due to the looming
    government shutdown. Without government funding, the FTC lawyers prolly wouldn't be able to show up for the hearing, said they. Accordingly said hearing was rescheduled for Friday, October 4. I guess they're optimistic that the government will be back in operation. If not, they can always reschedule. They seem to be good at that.

    Anyway, a flurry of new court documents appeared on September 30. There are three docs for the criminal case [1:10-cr-00886, Judge Ronald A. Guzmán presiding]. They are mostly about the pre-trial motions, which are still being argued back and forth endlessly, in preparation for the November 4 trial. And there was one doc for the civil case [1:03-cv-03904, Judge Robert Gettleman presiding], with a long exhibit attached.
    Here's a link to the civil document.

    The main document is "FTC’S STATEMENT REGARDING THE NEED FOR COERCIVE SANCTIONS" -- in other words, a recap of why the FTC thinks Katie needs to be thrown back in jail again unless one of three "precise purge conditions" can be met:

    1) He fully complies with this Court’s June 2, 2010 order (DE372);
    (2) He establishes that he has no present ability to comply with the Court’s
    June 2, 2010 order beyond what he has already done; or
    (3) He establishes that continued incarceration will not have a coercive effect.
    By and large this is more of the same old same-old that we've heard and read recently, but there's newer info too, including a summary of additional recent violations of the receivership order. According to the FTC, Trudeau has violated recent orders at least five times, which they recap in a footnote on page 1:
    As discussed further below, these five instances include: (1) failing to disclose the Australian account; (2) spending and transferring assets from that account; (3) destroying documents; (4) failing to disclose an offshore gaming account; and (5) lying to the Receiver, as the Receiver’s reports document. There are additional instances of noncooperation that the Receiver has asked the FTC not to raise because, in the Receiver’s view, doing so would impair the Receiver’s ability to recover certain assets.
    Lying to the receiver? That alone is enough to get Katie thrown back in a cage, according to the terms of the receivership agreement as I understand them. (By the way, In case you don't know about that Aussie account, here's the scoop.)

    If you've been reading some of the other recent court docs you'll recognize some of the items from the exhibit as well, but there are new items there too. It's all pretty interesting.

    Perhaps because the FTC is following Katie's advice to "look for the gold" in everything, the issue of Trudeau's gold purchases has appeared numerous times in the court docs over the past year or so (including in his ex-marketing guy
    Peter Wink's declaration to the FTC). And there's more in this latest doc about Katie's purchases over the past few years from Peter Ragnar's Golden Lyin'... I mean Golden LION Mint. In another footnote on page 1 of the main doc the FTC declares:
    As discussed further below, Trudeau purportedly could not remember any details regarding significant new evidence the Receiver discovered indicating that Trudeau acquired additional gold bars (beyond the ten already known) and gold coins between 2008 and 2011, see infra at 6, except to say that he thought his wife had them.
    Oddly enough, Ragnar has reportedly distanced himself recently from both Golden Lion Mint and Roaring Lion Publishing (perhaps leaving his bidness partner and Lion etc. co-founder Tony Balistreri dangling in the wind)? By the way, here's a Ripoff Report complaint about Golden Lion Mint, dated April 28, 2013. Quite a contrast from "Health Ranger" Mike Adams' glowing review back in December 2008. Seems like lots of Scamworlders have gold fever, including, of course, Loony Coldwell.

    I really do need to finish that blog post about Peter Ragnar, whose real name is Peter Lundell, and who has a very iffy past, like so many players in Scamworld. Ragnar certainly benefited from GIN, even after the sh-t started really hitting the fan. He is still being sought by various pro-GIN folks as well as some anti-GIN (but pro-Scamworld) factions. Here's one of numerous recent examples of two robbin' Peters flim-flamming in tandem...



    Ragnar is still
    waxing profound on Facebook and doing various webinars in conjunction with other hucksters, and in my opinion not being held accountable for his part in the huge GIN scam.

    But I digress. One point that the FTC is trying to make is that the receiver's investigation will exhaust all of the available resources if allowed to continue much longer. They apparently think that jailing KT may hurry things up. (Cue laugh track.)

    Says the FTC in its statement:

    Simply put, there is no realistic probability that the Receiver will locate the bulk of Trudeau’s assets without his cooperation, and there is zero probability that Trudeau will ever cooperate voluntarily....

    The continuation of the current collection plan has drained significant public resources in a fruitless attempt to collect Trudeau’s assets. Worse yet, without coercive incarceration, the costs of the Receivership almost certainly will outstrip the assets ultimately collected. Thus, the choice at this point is stark: either incarcerate Trudeau for however long it takes to coerce him to turn over all the assets he controls, or continue depleting the assets available to Trudeau’s victims. In the event that the Court chooses the latter, the FTC will of course follow any order of the Court, but it cannot continue wasting public funds chasing down the avalanche of Trudeau’s lies and deception. Unfortunately, absent coercive incarceration, there is nothing further the FTC reasonably can do to help Trudeau’s victims.

    So the FTC has given themselves an out, anyway. In another footnote they declare:
    There is nothing Trudeau can do to further the goals of the Receivership outside of prison that he cannot do from within prison. However, the FTC requests that any coercive incarceration order provide the Receiver with access to Trudeau in the event that the Receiver needs Trudeau to execute documents or make phone calls under the Receiver’s supervision.
    The subtext is that Trudeau can lie and deceive from jail just as easily as he can lie and deceive anywhere else. I guess the FTC is still holding out some hope (or is pretending they are holding out hope) that he can be "scared straight," but that hasn't worked out too well so far.

    What all of this jail talk is accomplishing is increasing his martyr/hero creds, and he still has a passionate and fairly large fan base.
    We visited some of them here the other day. An apparently larger group of the faithful are enthusiastically planning a GIN cruise on their own to replace the January 2014 GIN Leadership cruise, which the court-appointed receiver has postponed indefinitely. They even started a Facebook group to plan it. (I bet they end up getting better rates than they got with the Katie cruises, and they'll see (or not) how he was ripping them off.) One person on the group wrote:
    This up coming cruise will be a great event for all of us.
    We are doing this because a great man taught us how to dream big and how to look for the gold in everyone and everything. Most of all how to believe in our abilities to do for self. ( If it is to be it is up to me.) (if you can do it I can do it.)

    For some odd reason I was invited to join that group, but out of respect for their privacy I will not attempt to link to the group here and will not name it or any of the parties who are planning the cruise. Actually I think it's a good thing that they're planning for life without Katie, and I told 'em so. They deserve a good party after all they've been through. I don't think it's a good thing that they're still doing it all in His Holy Name, but so many people are still in denial. At least there is better and more objective information for them when they're ready for it, and they know where to find it. They know that they won't find that more objective info on Loony Coldwell's Facebook rants or his little brother Abe's YouTubes.

    By the by, on the September 30 civil document I linked to above, I didn't see a mention of the FTC's concern that the receiver is possibly running an illegal operation by keeping GIN open. Closing GIN may not be a top priority right now for the FTC, despite what was reportedly brought up in court
    during the September 18 hearing that ended up with Katie being incarcerated overnight, and despite what Loony (and his little bro) have been mouthing off about.

    Notwithstanding the forced joy of the alt-GIN cruise planners, once again it doesn't look real good for Katie at the moment, but you never know what might happen between now and October 4. And there's no guarantee right now that the hearing will happen even then, what with that gummit shutdown. And so the saga continues, with the Cosmic mantra once again playing in the background...

    No. Neat. And. Tidy. Endings.
    * * * * *
    Now more than ever, your donation is needed
    to help keep this Whirled spinning.
    Click here to donate via PayPal or debit/credit card.
    If that link doesn't work, send PayPal payment directly to

    scrivener66@hotmail.com
    or to
    cosmic.connie@juno.com
    If PayPal, be sure to specify that your contribution is a gift. Thank you!